So Jorge has retired, the big question is does he belong in the HoF? In my opinion, no, he was never more than average where it mattered, behind the plate, and although solid with the bat wasn't anything to write home about. Although he did seem to reserve his best for us!
Sure he was in a lot of All Star games, but that was entirely because of who he played for. Every year he was voted in there was at least one other catcher more deserving who had the misfortune to play for anther team.