Just got back from NYC, I did a lot of web-surfing trying to find places other than Foleys (great bar)... with not much success. The site below has some ideas, other than that I would suggest checking out all the Irish bars around Times Square (and ESPN there), and Brooklyn.
For the 1pm game against Texas I was in Stan's Bar outside the stadium at 11:15am.....it was loud and rammed (and 'usually busier') - not my ideal but a good experience. Fenway Park bars were much better.
http://www.sportstavern.com/newyork/nyc.html