One thing I've always loved to do is to hear tales of small-town "monsters," hauntings, you name it. I live in the south, which means I've heard everything from the truly interesting to the most off-the-wall stories you can imagine (The Bell Witch incident, loosely depicted in An American Haunting, happened ten minutes from my house).
If you have any stories, post them. Have a town ghost? Was there a UFO sighting that caused a stir? Perhaps an unknown creature was seen? Bigfoot,Roswell, lizard-men, Moth Man...every town has a story.